How to Return a The Paper Store Order, Including the 45-Day and 46-to-60-Day Windows

How official The Paper Store returns pages describe 45-day refund or exchange paths, 46-to-60-day in-store merchandise credit, mail returns that are ineligible for exchange, and official holiday-item deadlines, checked November 18, 2026.

How to Return a The Paper Store Order, Including the 45-Day and 46-to-60-Day Windows

Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. They do not influence our editorial conclusions. Read the disclosure.

Our pick

  1. Top pick

    The Paper Store

    The Paper Store is a specialty retailer of gifts, home decor, fashion, and jewelry at thepaperstore.com. Official pages describe a $75 free-standard-shipping th...

    See price at The Paper Store

Jump to the full guide

Returning a purchase to The Paper Store starts with two questions: was it bought online or in a physical store, and how long has it been since purchase? The answers determine where it can go and whether the likely outcome is a refund, merchandise credit, or a return that the published policy does not promise to accept.

This walkthrough is based on the retailer's return-policy page checked November 18, 2026. The page itself is marked “Updated 10/25/2024.” That date matters: we are explaining the policy currently displayed, not reporting a new 2026 return announcement. Always check the latest policy before sending merchandise, especially seasonal purchases and items marked final sale.

Alight snowflake embossed glass candle sold by The Paper Store

Step 1: check whether the item can be returned

The retailer requires merchandise to be in the manufacturer's saleable, like-new condition, with original packaging materials, the barcode or UPC label, accessories, and instructions. Customer-damaged merchandise is not accepted. Keep these requirements in mind before discarding a box or removing labels from a gift you might not keep.

The exclusions include final-sale items, clearance merchandise, gift cards, ear-piercing services, personalized or engraved products, and shipping and service charges. Holiday-themed merchandise has additional limits explained below. A receipt does not override a final-sale exclusion, and returning an ordinary product does not establish a right to recover the shipping charge.

Stanley products have a separate documentation rule: they must be accompanied by a receipt or order-confirmation email to be returnable or exchangeable, regardless of timeframe. Do not rely on the general no-receipt process for those products. If a product's classification is unclear, resolve it with the retailer before traveling or paying for postage.

Step 2: choose the route that matches the purchase

Online purchases have two published routes. You can take them to a store location across the retailer's brands, or mail them to its Returns Center. The retailer describes an in-person return as the quickest way to receive a refund. That does not mean every item is eligible, but it is a useful starting point for a straightforward documented return.

In-store purchases have only the in-person route described by the policy. They must be returned to a store; the page says they cannot be shipped to a store or to the Returns Center. Mailing a store purchase because a branch is inconvenient would therefore conflict with the stated instructions.

An online purchase sent by mail must go to the Returns Center, not to a store address. The distinction is easy to miss because a store may accept the same online item when you bring it in yourself. Acceptance in person is not permission to post it to that location.

Step 3: work out the applicable time window

For most eligible merchandise, the policy describes a refund, credit, or exchange within 45 days of purchase when proof of purchase is provided. Use purchase date as your planning anchor; the page does not describe the general clock as starting when the recipient opens a gift or when a parcel arrives.

For eligible items returned in-store 46–60 days after purchase with proof of purchase, the stated outcome is merchandise credit, not an original-payment refund. This is an in-store provision. Do not read it as a blanket 60-day mail-refund entitlement, because that is not what the detailed wording says.

A practical example: an otherwise eligible item brought to a store around day 30 with the original receipt is within the ordinary refund window. The same item brought around day 50 may be considered only for merchandise credit under the later window. This is an illustration of the policy structure, not a promise that an excluded or damaged item becomes returnable.

The page does not provide a general return entitlement beyond 60 days. If timing is close, contact the retailer rather than choosing the most generous interpretation. For mail returns, it is especially important to clarify deadline handling before dispatch; the page does not clearly settle every sent-date versus received-date scenario.

Step 4: bring the right proof for a store return

The original receipt supports a refund for the amount paid in the original payment form within the applicable window. A gift receipt instead leads to merchandise credit usable in-store or online. The giver and recipient should know that distinction before expecting money back to the recipient's own card.

Online purchases originally paid through PayPal have a specific exception: the policy says an in-store refund is issued as cash. This exception is tied to the purchase method and return route, not a general choice to demand cash for any transaction.

Without any receipt, the page says identifying information is required and Store Manager approval is necessary. If approved, the return produces merchandise credit at the item's current selling price. Approval is discretionary; it is not a guaranteed receipt-replacement service. A later lower selling price could therefore affect the value received compared with the amount originally paid.

The policy also says the retailer monitors returns and reserves the right to refuse them. Bring all available documentation and ask staff to explain the applicable route, rather than treating a missing receipt as a minor administrative detail.

Step 5: prepare an online purchase for mailing

For an online mail return, include a copy of the order-confirmation email and a completed Return Merchandise Authorization form. The return-policy page links to the printable RMA. Follow that current form for the Returns Center details rather than copying an address from an old article, search snippet, or parcel label.

If you no longer have the order confirmation, the retailer directs you to customer service. Reconstruct the documentation before dispatching an unidentifiable package. Make sure the items, packaging, labels, accessories, and instructions meet the stated condition requirements.

The page says mail returns are eligible for a full refund but are ineligible for exchange. If you want a different item rather than a refund, do not write “exchange” on the form and assume the warehouse will fulfill a replacement. Ask about an eligible in-store exchange or the appropriate purchase-and-return route instead.

The page does not clearly promise prepaid return postage in the text reviewed. Do not assume a free label will be supplied. Confirm the instructions and costs before sending the parcel. As a practical precaution, retain dispatch proof and tracking for your records; that recommendation is ours, not a claim that a particular carrier is required by the retailer.

Step 6: apply holiday rules before the everyday clock

Holiday-themed items generally cannot be returned after the holiday; the policy illustrates this with Valentine's Day items after February 14. Christmas and Hanukkah merchandise has a distinct rule: it follows the normal 60-day deadline but cannot be returned after January 15. Hallmark Keepsake Ornaments similarly follow that deadline but cannot be returned after December 24.

These dates are caps, not universal extensions. The phrase “normal 60-day” does not turn every return into a 60-day cash refund, and January 15 does not automatically give an early purchase more than 60 days. Read the seasonal cap alongside the ordinary timing and refund-method rules.

For example, a Christmas-themed gift bought shortly before Christmas should not be assumed returnable well into February simply because 60 days would extend that far. The January cap can arrive first. A Keepsake Ornament has a different cap, so a generic holiday-return reminder may not be enough.

Step 7: allow processing time, then follow up with records

For online purchases mailed to the Returns Center, the retailer says refunds may take 7–10 business days to process. That is not a guarantee that a bank balance updates the day you hand a parcel to a carrier. Keep the order confirmation, RMA copy, tracking, and any acknowledgement together so a follow-up can refer to the same transaction.

If you are still choosing a gift, our shipping and pickup guide addresses fulfillment, while the selected-price guide separates product cost from delivery. Readers browsing through our Paper Store link should know it is an affiliate redirect that may earn Brands Review a commission. Neither the link nor this guide changes the retailer's return decision.

References

Meet your guide

Lipeiguan

author